FORTUNE ARTERIAL: Akai Yakusoku

Fortune Arterial's story revolves around the male protagonist Kohei Hasekura, who transfers into a prestigious public school in the style of an English six-year school encompassing junior-high and high school students. The school is on an island named Tamatsu Island off-shore from mainland Japan, and the only way to get there is by boat. Soon after transferring, he discovers that one of the student in the class next door to his, Sendo Erika, is in fact a type of vampire.

If you like this, try

A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd 89%

12 eps · 2014

A library club fills up with girls one by one, giving you the same slow-building female harem warmth around a quiet protagonist.

Karin: Chibi Vampire 84%

24 eps · 2005

Karin flips the vampire-in-school setup on its head, but keeps that same kuudere-tinged supernatural romance you fell for.

Princess Lover! 82%

12 eps · 2009

Trade the vampire mystery for palace intrigue, but the school setting and adoring circle of girls around one lucky guy stays intact.

Tayutama: Kiss on my Deity 81%

12 eps · 2009

Swap fangs for shrine gods and you still get a normal-seeming boy suddenly surrounded by a harem of supernatural women.