Kimagure Orange★Road

It can be hard moving to a new school, and fifteen-year-old Kyosuke has it harder than most. He’s fallen head over heels for his classmate Madoka, a girl who won’t even give him the time of day, and unintentionally ended up dating her best friend, Hikaru, instead. Worst of all, Kyosuke and his family have amazing supernatural powers, but he has to keep them hidden from the rest of the world! How is Kyosuke ever going to balance the affections (or lack thereof) of two girls, schoolwork, and his secret abilities all at the same time?

If you like this, try

Maison Ikkoku 83%

96 eps · 1986

From the same creator's pen, it trades the love triangle's teen jitters for slow-burn cohabitation, but keeps that same episodic will-they charm.

Urusei Yatsura 83%

195 eps · 1981

This one gives you the same episodic alien-powered chaos wrapped around a boy who can't quite handle the girl who won't leave him alone.

Touch 76%

101 eps · 1985

Swap super-powers for baseball, and you still get a love triangle tangled up with twins and quiet sibling rivalry.

Tokimeki Tonight 72%

34 eps · 1982

A girl hiding supernatural family secrets while juggling romantic entanglements gives you the same fantasy-meets-teen-life mix you loved.